Silent Hill games scare the crap out of me and I've never picked up a controller on one, except for a brief stint of Silent hill 3. I've seen others play it though and it's creepy as hell.
The only "scary" game I've completed on my own is a little backwater game called Extermination . This game, for being so action-oriented, scared the crap out of me. It instilled a sense of psychological thriller, added simple mechanics which meant more bang for your buck, but allowed a certain degree of freedom.
The journal fragments and articles you could pick up and read along the way made it even scarier, some of the enemies were downright gruesome, and best of all this game was genuinely scary.
Not just on a "I'm watching a scary movie" level, but also in the sense of immersion you get when playing a game. Limited health and ammo make you have to play it safe, and walking into a dark corridor filled with monsters you can't see will kick your self-preservation instincts into overdrive (often causing you to slam the trigger and waste ammo, which hurts you later on).
If you haven't played it, I highly reccomend it at least once.
(I once wrote a complete walkthrough of the game, but it has dissapeared off the face of the planet, which makes me sad...
Anybody know any other good scary games?
---
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extermination_(video_game)















